The two most important factors that must be considered when forming a business are its legal business structure and business jurisdiction. In today’s business environment, location can affect a business’s efficiency, effectiveness and sustainability.
Given that entrepreneurship is largely associated with the US, many businessmen have a perception that it is the most suitable country for establishing and operating a successful business. But in today’s competitive business environment, the advantages that once existed for forming a business in the US are less significant than in previous years. To be competitive, countries such as Singapore that have created business friendly policies offer much better opportunities for entrepreneurs.
Singapore’s emergence and dominance as a favorable business location is further enhanced by its exceptional performance in recent business surveys and economic indicators. The results provided by a comparative analysis of international rankings illustrate the significant differences in doing business in Singapore and US.
- Singapore receiving the #1 position in the World Bank’s ‘2016 Ease of Doing Business Report’ signifies that it has the most productive regulatory environment for doing business among 183 economies worldwide. The US ranked seventh, pointing out that higher challenges are expected when doing business in the country. For example, company incorporation in Singapore requires just two procedures and can be completed within 24 hours. On the other hand, company incorporation in the US involves six procedures over six days. The most glaring differences were seen in the areas of taxes and trading across borders. Singapore’s ranks #5 for paying taxes while the US’s rank is #53. Singapore was rated as #1 for ease of enforcing contracts while the US was ranked #21.
- The highly reputable Forbes magazine ranked Singapore #8 in its ‘2015 Best Countries to Do Business’ list, but the US came in ranked as #22. Singapore led the US in most areas including trading without many restrictions, monetary policies, property rights, advanced technology, red tape interference, the protection of investors, the least amount of corruption, and not having to deal with frustrating tax burdens.
Related Article: Why Singapore is a preferred business location for company setup?
- The US has a reputation for having one of the harshest tax systems in the world, presenting difficulties for business start-ups. In sharp contrast, Singapore’s tax system and favorable tax rates encourage the spirit of business development and entrepreneurship.
- Forbes’ ‘2009 Tax Misery & Reform Index’ ranked Singapore #11 in the world, demonstrating its low tax burden. The US was ranked #18.
- The widening gap with regards to the tax environments of both countries is also highlighted in Forbes’ ‘2015 Best Countries for Business’ list where Singapore’s tax burden was ranked highly at #4 while the US’ tax burden was ranked at a low #42.
- The World Economic Forum’s (WEF) ‘2015 – 2016 Global Competitiveness Report’ ranked Singapore as #10 worldwide for its total tax rate while the US was ranked significantly lower at #95.
Related Article: Singapore Corporate Tax Guide
Intellectual Property Protection
- Singapore has positioned itself as the one-stop center for businesses to manage their intellectual property assets due to its strong intellectual property protection system. Forbes magazine ranked Singapore #5 for property rights in its ‘2015 Best Countries for Business’ list while the US was far behind in the fifteenth spot.
- The WEF’s ‘2015 – 2016 Global Competitiveness Report’ ranked Singapore’s intellectual property protection system as #4 in the world while US’s intellectual property protection system lagged behind at #15.
Related Article: 5 Options for Protecting Your Intellectual Property in Singapore
Competitiveness on a Global Scale
- Singapore’s economy was ranked significantly higher as the second most competitive in the world by the WEF in its ‘2015 – 2016 Global Competitiveness Report’. Singapore’s educational institutions were ranked as the world’s best and the country also received top recognition for its lack of corruption and government efficiency. Singapore was recognized as first and second respectively, for the efficiency of its goods and labor markets, second for its financial market performance, while its infrastructure is ranked as the second best in the world. The US was only one step behind Singapore, ranking #3 for overall competitiveness. Factors that weakened the US’s position were the wasteful government spending, goods and market inefficiency and technology preparation.
- The Heritage Foundation’s ‘2015 Index of Economic Freedom’ ranked Singapore in the second spot, ahead of the US, which was given the 12th rank. Singapore was ahead of the US in almost all areas including the ease of ability to start, operate and close a business; the ease of ability to trade across borders; the staunch protection of property rights and freedom from corruption. Taxation and government spending were two areas where the US ranked considerably poorly as compared to Singapore. Singapore’s top corporate income tax of 17% is significantly lower the US’s top corporate tax rate of 35%. Government spending contributed to 12.5% of Singapore’s GDP in 2009, while in the US it accounted for 37.4% of its GDP.
- The US once again claimed the top position in the IMD’s ‘2015 World Competitiveness Yearbook’ claiming the position as the world’s most competitive economy. Singapore was not far behind, claiming the third slot.
Related Article: Types of Business Entities in Singapore
Ease of Trade
- The WEF’s ‘Global Enabling Trade Report 2014’ ranks Singapore #1 for ease of trade while the US was ranked #15. Singapore’s open trade policy provides very few restrictions for traders. The country’s strengths are its simple tariff structure, exceptional border administration, high quality of transport infrastructure and superior customs services.
Related Article: Starting a Trading Company in Singapore
- The ‘2010 Global Innovation Index’ released by INSEAD and the Confederation of Indian Industry identified Singapore as the world’s seventh most innovative economy while the US slipped to the 11th place. Singapore’s strengths that provide for its ability to succeed in innovation were its free market fundamentals and corrupt-free environment. The US relinquished its previously held #1 position due to its political and regulatory environment, technological infrastructure and human capital.
Related Article: Why Entrepreneurs Are Choosing to Do Business in Singapore
- Singapore’s efficient government enhances its attractiveness as an investment destination. According to the WEF, Singapore has the highest public trust in politicians, least burden of government regulation, and highest transparency of government policy making. The US ranking lagged far behind at #54, #49, and #41 on the same indicators.
- Singapore’s score in Transparency International’s ‘2015 Corruption Perceptions Index’ was #8 while US’ score was #16.
Related Article: Singapore Productivity and Innovation Credit (PIC) Scheme
- Singapore is reported to have topped BERI’s ‘Labor Force Evaluation Measure’ for 31 years, illustrating that its human capital is the world’s best. The US is ranked as the second best in the world in this year’s survey.
- According to the WEF, Singapore is reported to have the best labor-employer relations and the most productive workforce in the world. The US ranked #33 and #9 on both these parameters.
- According to the IMD’s ‘World Competitiveness Yearbook 2010’, Singapore ranks #2 for favorable business labor regulations while the US ranked #12.
Related Article: Singapore Work Visa and Immigration Services
Quality of Life
- In recent times, Singapore has topped several polls measuring the quality of life, positioning itself as Asia’s top destination for expats.
- Singapore is the ‘Best Place to Live’ for Asian expats according to ECA International’s ‘2010 Location Ratings System’.
- Gallup’s ‘2010 Potential Net Migration Index’ identified the city-state as the most attractive country for immigrants.
- The ‘2015 Quality of Living Survey’ by Mercer Human Resource Consulting regarded Singapore as providing ‘The best Quality of Life in Asia.’
- According to the ‘2010 IMD World Competitiveness Yearbook’, foreign talent ranked Singapore as the world’s second best country to work in.
- HSBC’s ‘Expat Explorer Survey 2014‘ placed Singapore in the 2nd spot and downgraded the US to the 30th position.
Related Article: Singapore Rankings 2015
At-a-glance Country Rankings: Singapore vs. the United States
|Year||Category||Singapore’s Rank||US’ Rank||Source|
|2016||Ease of Doing Business||1||7||World Bank, Ease of Doing Business Report|
|2015 – 2016||World’s Most Competitive Economy||2||3||World Economic Forum, Global Competitiveness Report|
|2015||World’s Best Country for Business||8||22||Forbes Best Countries for Business List|
|2015||World’s Freest Economy||2||12||Heritage Foundation’s Index of Economic Freedom|
|2015||City with Best Quality of Living||26||27||Mercer’s Quality of Living Survey|
|2015||Country with Least Corruption Perception||8||16||Transparency International’s Corruption Perceptions Index|
|2015||World’s Most Competitive Economy||3||1||IMD, World Competitiveness Yearbook|
|2014||Country Most Open to Trade||1||15||World Economic Forum, Global Enabling Trade Report|
|2010||World’s Most Innovative Economy||7||11||INSEAD and the Confederation of Indian Industry’s Global Innovation Index|
|2010||World’s Most Economically Globalized Country||1||57||KOF Index of Globalization|
|2010||World’s Best Labor Force||1||2||BERI’s Labor Force Evaluation Measure|
|2009||Country with Lowest Tax Misery||11||18||Forbes Tax Misery and Reform Index|
The information provided by the comparative analysis above indicates that Singapore has a better business environment for both large multi-national companies and small start-ups in comparison to the US.
Moving forward, Singapore is prepared to introduce more initiatives that will continue its dominance as a preferred location to do business. The country is more than willing to invest heavily in the continued success of its business infrastructure.
Looking to start your Business in Singapore?
Rikvin has been the leader in business entities, company incorporation, legal and tax, you can drop in our office for a free non-obligatory consultation.